When Defacing a Poster Goes Too Far: The Presidency University Incident

The incident dates back to October 14, when the ABVP complained that obscene words had been written on one of its posters, carrying an image of Swami Vivekananda, pasted on a campus wall .

Ah, university life! A place for learning, forming lifelong friendships, and, apparently, defacing posters of revered figures. Yes, you heard that right. Recently, two female students at Presidency University in Kolkata found themselves in hot water—or should I say, hot seat—after they decided it was a good idea to deface a poster of none other than Swami Vivekananda. Spoiler alert: it wasn’t a good idea.

So, what exactly happened? According to reports, these students took it upon themselves to not only deface the poster but also scribble some rather colorful remarks aimed at other organizations. Now, I’m all for free speech and expressing one’s opinions, but there’s a fine line between ‘voicing your thoughts’ and ‘getting yourself expelled.’ And let’s just say, they crossed that line with a flourish.

The university, in its infinite wisdom (and perhaps a sprinkle of exasperation), conducted an inquiry. This involved reviewing CCTV footage—because nothing says ‘serious investigation’ quite like a security camera replay—and gathering testimonies. It turns out that the evidence was compelling enough to warrant expulsion. Yes, ladies and gentlemen, these students are now officially barred from future academic activities at the institution. Talk about a dramatic plot twist in their educational saga!

But wait, there’s more! The Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP), the student organization that raised a ruckus over this incident, didn’t just sit back and let the university handle it. Oh no! They lodged a police complaint, calling for a thorough investigation. Because when you deface a poster, it’s not just a university issue; it’s a matter for the police. Who knew that a piece of art could spark such a legal kerfuffle?

Now, let’s take a moment to appreciate the irony here. Swami Vivekananda was known for his teachings on tolerance, respect, and the importance of education. I can’t help but wonder what he would have thought about this incident. Would he have been disappointed? Amused? Or perhaps he would have just chuckled and said, ‘Kids these days!’

This incident raises some important questions about campus life and the boundaries of expression. When does a protest or an opinion cross over into disrespect? And how do universities balance the need for free speech with maintaining a respectful environment? It’s a tricky tightrope walk, for sure.

In a world where social media is often the battleground for opinions, it’s a reminder that physical actions still carry weight—and consequences. So, to those aspiring to make their voices heard, maybe consider less destructive methods? Perhaps a well-written article, a peaceful protest, or even a good old-fashioned debate could be more effective than a spray can and a poster? Just a thought!

As for the two students, their academic journey has taken an unexpected detour. Let’s hope they learn from this experience and find a more constructive way to express their views in the future. Because, at the end of the day, education is about growth, and hopefully, this will be a lesson in more ways than one.


Inspired by: “Presidency University expels two students over defacement of Swami Vivekananda poster” (r/News)