The Great Quarterback Debate: Why Brent Venables Didn’t Bench John Mateer Against Georgia

The Oklahoma Sooners did more than struggle on Saturday against the Georgia Bulldogs. In fact, they almost benched quarterback John Mateer at the half. That would happen if you went into the half down 28-0. George Stoia of Soonerscoop.com reported that Venables, during his postgame press conference, said they discussed possibly benching Mateer.

Ah, the joys of college football! It’s like a rollercoaster ride where you’re not quite sure if you’re going to scream in joy or horror at any given moment. This past Saturday, Oklahoma faced off against the mighty Georgia Bulldogs, and let’s just say it was a game that left many of us questioning our life choices, especially if you were rooting for the Sooners.

John Mateer, the Sooner quarterback, had a game that can only be described as a wild mix of highs and lows—think of it as a soap opera where the plot twists are just as confusing as they are dramatic. He completed 25 out of 34 passes, racking up 231 yards and two touchdowns. Sounds good, right? Well, hold on to your helmets because he also threw an interception and lost two fumbles. One of those fumbles was so catastrophic it led to a touchdown for the Georgia defense. Ouch!

The question on everyone’s mind (besides why we willingly put ourselves through this torture) is: Why didn’t head coach Brent Venables bench Mateer at halftime? I mean, it’s not like he was auditioning for a role in a quarterback-themed horror movie.

According to reports, Venables did consider making a change at the half. Perhaps he was daydreaming about how much easier life would be if he could just swap Mateer out for a human cannonball or something equally absurd. But in the end, he decided against it. Maybe he thought Mateer could turn it around, or perhaps he just wanted to give him a chance to redeem himself. After all, nothing says “I believe in you” quite like letting your quarterback get tackled a few more times.

Now, let’s talk about the implications of this decision. Venables is a seasoned coach, and he knows that sometimes you have to let your players learn from their mistakes—even if those mistakes are like a series of unfortunate events strung together. By opting to keep Mateer in the game, he was likely hoping for a moment of brilliance to shine through the chaos.

But let’s be real: the game was already spiraling out of control. Georgia was like a well-oiled machine, and the Sooners looked like they were still trying to figure out how to turn on their engines. Keeping Mateer in the game might have been a gamble, but sometimes you have to roll the dice and hope for a miracle.

So what’s next for John Mateer and the Oklahoma Sooners? Well, they’ll have to regroup and figure out how to turn this ship around before they find themselves lost at sea. For Mateer, it’s a chance to reflect on what went wrong and hopefully learn from it. And for Venables, it’s a reminder that coaching is as much about making tough decisions as it is about hoping for the best (and maybe a little bit of magic).

In conclusion, while we might not have seen the quarterback change everyone was hoping for at halftime, it’s a reminder that sometimes you just have to ride out the storm. After all, every great quarterback has their off days. Here’s hoping Mateer can bounce back and give us a game that doesn’t make us question our sanity next time around.

Until then, let’s keep our fingers crossed and our snacks handy for the next game!


Inspired by: “Brent Venables considered benching John Mateer at halftime of Georgia game, decided against it” (r/Sport)