Chasing Gold: The Frequent Flyer Dilemma Between Qantas and the Best in Class

While Qantas Silver is an entry-level tier to reward those who travel a little, Qantas Gold is tailored towards those who do a fair chunk of travel each year . If frequent flyer status were a meal, Qantas Silver would be the appetiser and Qantas …

Ah, the age-old question in the frequent flyer community: Should I stick with my airline loyalty program, or should I chase after the elusive best-in-class experience? If you’re anything like our friend over on Reddit, who just started a new job that involves travel (lucky them!), you may find yourself grappling with this very dilemma. Let’s dive into it, shall we?

The Background

So, you’re flying from Sydney to JFK around twice a year, and maybe a jaunt to London every 18 months. Sounds like a solid plan! Previously, you enjoyed a luxurious flight with Etihad (which, let’s be honest, could probably make a cardboard box feel like first class) and had a decent experience with Qantas (QF). Now, you’re a Silver pleb dreaming of Gold status.

The Quest for Gold

Now, let’s talk about that shiny Gold status. We all know it’s not just about the perks; it’s about the bragging rights. You want to feel important, like you’ve achieved something monumental, like climbing Everest but without the frostbite and the questionable air quality.

But here’s the rub: does Gold status really matter if you’re not traveling with family often? You mention that when you do travel with the fam, you’re just looking for the cheapest fare. It’s hard to flash that Gold card when you’re trying to save a few bucks on a family ticket. Plus, your work trips are usually business class anyway, so you’re already enjoying those sweet, sweet perks without needing to wave around a Gold card.

The Alternatives

Now, let’s get into the meat of your post: should you continue with Qantas or explore other carriers like ANA or Air New Zealand? It’s a question as old as time. Well, maybe not quite that old, but you get the point.

1. Stick with Qantas: If you’re already flying QF3 and have a decent experience with them, it might make sense to stick with the devil you know. The more you fly, the closer you get to that Gold status. Plus, there’s something comforting about the familiar. It’s like a warm blanket on a cold night, or that slightly stale but oh-so-comforting pizza in your fridge at 2 AM.

2. Best in Class: On the flip side, why not treat yourself to a premium experience? Airlines like ANA and Air New Zealand have stellar reputations. If you fly with them, you might find that the journey itself becomes part of the adventure, not just a means to an end. Who doesn’t want to sip on a fancy cocktail while being pampered by attentive staff?

The Conclusion

Ultimately, the choice is yours. If you’re leaning towards Qantas just for the status and a bit of self-importance, remember that sometimes, the journey is more important than the destination. If you can snag a better experience with another airline, it might be worth it to take that leap.

In the end, whether you’re a Silver pleb or a Gold connoisseur, what truly matters is enjoying your travels and making the most of your time in the air. So go forth, happy flying, and may your status dreams come true—whatever that may look like for you!


Inspired by: “Options for Syd to JFK or just chase status on Q?” (r/QantasFrequentFlyer)